General2 min read

AFT Report Documents How Private Equity Looted Steward Health Care Into $9B Bankruptcy

The American Federation of Teachers has published a detailed report documenting how private equity ownership contributed to the collapse of Steward Health Care, which filed the largest bankruptcy in American healthcare history at approximately $9 billion in liabilities. The report traces how Cerberus Capital Management's ownership model extracted value through sale-leaseback transactions on hospital real estate, management fees, and dividend recapitalizations — financial engineering that left Steward's hospitals operationally fragile while generating returns for investors. The bankruptcy has disrupted care for communities across multiple states, forcing emergency sales and closures of hospitals that serve vulnerable populations.

The Steward collapse is the most vivid example yet of a pattern that healthcare policy experts have warned about for years: PE ownership models that prioritize financial returns over operational sustainability. The sale-leaseback strategy — selling hospital real estate to a PE-affiliated REIT and then leasing it back at market rates — converted owned assets into fixed obligations, dramatically increasing operating costs while generating one-time cash that could be distributed to investors. This same playbook has been deployed in dental (Aspen Dental's real estate strategy), veterinary (NVA, VCA), and behavioral health. The AFT report provides a comprehensive case study that regulators and legislators will reference for years.

For the broader healthcare industry, including dental, the Steward bankruptcy carries direct implications. State legislatures are already using Steward as justification for PE transparency and oversight legislation — Oregon's SB 951, which restricts PE and MSO consolidation in healthcare, was influenced by similar concerns. The financial techniques documented in the AFT report — sale-leasebacks, dividend recaps, management fee extraction — are common across PE-backed healthcare platforms including DSOs. If regulators begin restricting these practices in hospital settings, the restrictions will likely expand to ambulatory care, dental, and other PE-heavy healthcare sectors.

Watch for whether the Steward case generates federal legislation. Several bills targeting PE in healthcare are already moving through Congress (covered separately in today's briefing). The AFT report will be cited extensively in upcoming Senate HELP Committee hearings. For dental industry stakeholders, monitor whether PE-backed DSOs proactively modify their financial structures — reducing leverage, limiting dividend recaps, retaining real estate ownership — to avoid the regulatory backlash that Steward has accelerated.